Jonathan, I think I hear in you what was me for many years. Since I was so sure that the Bible was inspired by God (this is what my parents trained me to believe), I had no interest in exploring things like evolution. I have come to believe that that is far more likely than an all powerful god coming out of nothing who did not even have a beginning. Think about that.
Check out this article...you might be surprised at how many Christians now accept that evolution has to be true. Do take care. Why do so many People still believe that Adam and Eve were Real?